Two-story off-white brick house with black-framed windows, a deep front lawn, and a mature tree canopy.

The Grocery Store You're Shopping In Used to Be Your Library

Walk into the Niemann Harvest Market at 2140 East 116th Street on a Saturday morning and you will see produce stacked by the entrance, a butcher counter working through a line of orders, and a coffee bar pouring espresso for people waiting on the Farmhouse Restaurant to seat them. Nothing about it suggests that just four years ago you would have walked through this exact doorway to return a library book.

That is not a metaphor. From 2020 to 2022, while the Carmel Clay Public Library's main branch on Main Street underwent renovation, this building served as the library's temporary home. Before that, for decades, it was a Marsh grocery store. Marsh collapsed as a chain in 2017 and the space sat empty until the library needed somewhere to put its collection during construction. Once the renovation finished and the library moved back downtown, the building went quiet again until Niemann Foods, an Illinois-based grocery company, opened its first Indiana location there in May 2024.

That is the part of East Carmel's story that gets lost when people talk about what is "new" at Merchants Square. The building did not get replaced. It got reused for a third time. And this fall, the intersection that sits right outside its front doors is under construction, which means the way East Carmel residents reach Merchants Square has temporarily changed too, while the quieter park a mile east that most of them also use remains unaffected.

Three Lives, One Building

The scale of the current use is worth sitting with for a second. Niemann's Harvest Market occupies 75,000 square feet, which is roughly the footprint of the Marsh store it replaced. Inside, the layout puts produce immediately past the entrance, with prepared food and the restaurant to one side and standard grocery aisles to the other, a deliberate departure from the freezer-and-cereal-aisle geography that defined the space when it was still stocking cereal boxes as library shelving. The old butcher counter section, where the store now does on-demand meat cutting, once held the audiobook collection.

None of this is trivia for its own sake. It says something about how this particular stretch of East Carmel changes. A lot of suburban retail growth in Hamilton County happens by clearing a lot and building something new. This corner did the opposite. The same four walls have now hosted a regional grocery chain, a public library, and another regional grocery chain, in that order, without anyone tearing anything down.

What Is Actually There Now

Merchants Square as a whole has more going on than the anchor tenant. The center currently holds Planet Fitness, Flix Brewhouse, Cost Plus World Market, Petco, and Dollar Tree alongside Harvest Market, which functions as a shadow anchor pulling foot traffic to the rest of the row. That is a different mix than what stood there when Marsh was still open, and it reflects the broader pattern of the past two years: a shopping center that had struggled with vacancies is now full enough that the parking lot on Harvest Market's opening weekend reportedly overflowed into the lots of neighboring stores.

Here is how the two anchors that bookend a typical East Carmel week actually compare right now:

Merchants Square (Harvest Market anchor) Flowing Well Park
Address 2140 E. 116th St. 5100 E. 116th St.
What changed recently Grocery reopened May 2024 after years as a temporary library Nothing structural in years
What you'd go for Groceries, a sit-down meal, a movie at Flix Brewhouse, a Planet Fitness workout A dog walk, the artesian well, a quiet trail loop
Current disruption Access route via 116th & AAA Way affected by construction expected to run through October 2026 Unaffected by the roundabout work
Feel Busy, full parking lot, turnover in tenants Same 1-mile loop it has always been

The two points sit less than a mile apart on the same stretch of 116th Street, which is close enough that most residents treat them as part of the same errand loop. That is exactly what makes the current construction worth knowing about.

The Roundabout Between Them

On Monday, July 13, 2026, the City of Carmel fully closed the intersection of 116th Street and AAA Way to build a new roundabout in place of the existing traffic signal. The city expects the project to wrap up in October, part of a broader stretch of summer and fall roadwork that also includes the Main Street reconstruction between Old Meridian and Guilford Road and continued Monon Boulevard Phase III work.

Access to the businesses inside Merchants Square and the surrounding Pointe Parkway area has stayed open throughout the closure, but getting there requires a genuine detour rather than a straight shot down 116th. The city's posted routes send drivers coming from the west and east along different paths, and anyone heading south past Merchants Square toward the FedEx, Harvest Market, and Petco cluster is being routed via Keystone Parkway instead of the closed intersection. If you have not driven this corner since mid-July, the direct route you remember is not the one that works right now.

The rationale behind the full closure, rather than a slower partial one, comes down to cost. City officials estimated a full closure saves several hundred thousand dollars over a phased approach, which is presumably why residents are dealing with a hard detour for a few months instead of a longer, softer disruption spread across next year.

A Mile East, Nothing Has Changed

Flowing Well Park sits far enough off the main corridor that the roundabout work has not touched it at all, and that stillness is part of what makes it worth mentioning alongside Merchants Square rather than instead of it. The park's centerpiece is an artesian well that locals have nicknamed Old Faithful, where people still show up with empty jugs to fill them with cold groundwater the way they have for years. Carmel Clay Parks and Recreation tests the well monthly in partnership with the city's water department, going beyond the quarterly testing artesian wells are legally required to receive.

The park itself covers roughly 15 acres, threaded by a mile-long dirt trail that crosses Cool Creek several times over a series of small bridges. It functions as an unofficial dog park even though it was never built as one. Dogs wade in the creek on leash while their owners walk the loop, which takes most people somewhere between 20 and 30 minutes depending on how many times they stop at the water. None of this has changed in the years people have been writing about it, and that consistency is the point. While Merchants Square cycles through tenants and rebuilds its anchor for a third time, Flowing Well Park has stayed exactly as low key as it has always been.

Two Corners, One Mile Apart

The interesting thing about East Carmel right now is not that one corner is new and the other is old. It is that both corners are telling you something true about how this part of the neighborhood works. Merchants Square shows a place willing to gut and refill the same building three times over rather than abandon the lot. Flowing Well Park shows a place that leaves well enough alone when something already works. Most neighborhoods lean one direction or the other. East Carmel does both, within a mile of each other, which is easy to miss until a construction closure forces you to actually think about the route connecting them.

If you are planning a Saturday that includes both a grocery run and a dog walk between now and October, budget a few extra minutes for the detour. The destinations have not moved. The way you get there has.

If you are curious what else has shifted in this part of Carmel or want a closer look at the neighborhood beyond this one intersection, Lauren Hewitt keeps a running read on East Carmel worth bookmarking. Reach out anytime with questions about the area, whether you are settling in for years or just trying to figure out the best way around a roundabout.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

Work With Lauren

Lauren Hewitt is a trusted partner and advocate for her clients. With extensive expertise in the local market and a proven track record of delivering results, she is committed to delivering an exceptional experience. Lauren specializes in buying, selling, relocation and new construction in the greater Indianapolis area. Reach out today to schedule a consultation.

Follow Me On Instagram